DaFireMedic Junior Member Joined: Aug 24, 2017 Messages: 3,947 Likes Received: 4,862 Aug 7, 2019 #21 You are correct. Apparently, Phillips was eligible because he did not play 4 games last season, meaning he could count it as his redshirt. That was before Martell's case, where the NCAA got criticized for creating "free agency". Fair or not, I don't think they will approve Bru's waiver. The NCAA may have "clarified" their criteria, but they are still pretty darn muddy, and there doesn't seem to be any source to go to for clear criteria on what qualifies for a waiver. KANDI11 likes this.